Subscribe to continue reading
Subscribe to get access to the rest of this post and other subscriber-only content.
Category Archives: People
George and Emma Fetters and Their Resort
The success of the resort founded by Henry and Antoinette Boyes proved to be an example to others. In 1907, a couple from Pittsburg (Emma was originally from Austria) by way of San Francisco, George and Emma Fetters, bought the old Halstead ranch just a mile north of the Boyes’ property. Robert Halstead (“a wealthy sugar planter from Hawaii” according to the Index Tribune) had bought the property from E.P. Thomson, who planted olive trees on it in the 1880s. Many of those now large trees are still there.
George had been in the hotel business in Pittsburg. The money for the land and the ambition to open a resort were mostly Emma’s. The next year they opened Fetters Hot Springs Resort. Soon after, they leased their resort to Morris Levy, a prize fight promoter from San Francisco, who renamed it Eleda Hot Springs.
The Fetters took over operation again in 1911. In 1913, apparently bearing a grudge over losing the lease to the resort, Levy testified in opposition to a liquor license being granted to Fetters. They received the license, but this would not be the first time the Fetters got into legal trouble over liquor. In 1918 they were tried for the offense of providing liquor to enlisted men (a crime under the War Emergency Act.)
Testifying in their defense were “Fred Boyngton, the well known lumber yard man, E.G. Koenig of Boyes Springs, and Lillian the “entertainer,” among others.” Despite Lillian, both Fetters were convicted, but George’s conviction was overturned on appeal. Emma’s sentence was later commuted. Both George and Emma were in and out of court many times, being sued for damages by resort guests, and once for libel.
The Fetters were constantly improving the resort, bringing in moving pictures in 1923, sidewalks in 1924,and a new dance hall in 1925. George donated the land for the Boyes Springs ball field, and at its dedication in 1940, he threw out the first ball.
According to the Index Tribune, Emma Fetters was “an energetic woman of wealth and enterprise.” The Fetters built not only the resort, with its hotel, swimming pavilion and theater, but the Fetters Depot of the Northwest Pacific Railroad. Mrs. Fetters also owned much real estate in the area, and once owned the Chauvet Hotel in Glen Ellen.
In 1923 a movie company came to town and shot some scenes in and around Fetters Resort (and that’a another story!)
The resort era continued into the 1950s and beyond. Photo courtesy of Sonoma County Library.
The notorious and beloved, by some, Juanita Musson operated her restaraunt in the hotel from 1969 to 1975. I havn’t written a post soley devoted to Juanita, yet, but more here.
The hotel burned down in 1975.
In 2009 this was all that was left of Fetters Resort. It appears to be “Bachelors Row,” shown above. I met Juanita when she lived in one of these cabins. Authors photo.
Emma Fetters died in 1922, of pneumonia. George was a prominent member of the community and continued to run the resort until he sold in 1944. He died in 1964. Interesting that the gravestone omits the S at the end of the name.
Fetters Resort is well photo-documented. A few bonus images below.
The Depot: 1979, 2008 ,2016.
Harmonie Ausflug
A curiosity of early 20th century postcards from the Boyes Hot Springs resort are labeled “Harmonie Ausflug.” “Harmonie Ausflug” is not the name of a specific society but of the activity: the Harmonie (singing society, choral group,) takes an outing.
Livia Gershon in JSTOR Daily:
“In Europe’s German-speaking states…male choir organizations started popping up around 1810 and grew in number and prominence over the next half-century. Most were open to people of different social classes and focused on the idea of educating people and spreading middle-class values-though, by the 1860s, some were specifically “workers choirs,” affiliated with socialist and labor movements.
However, for many regular German Americans, this wasn’t really the point of the festivals. They showed up to enjoy romantic or humorous folk songs, eat childhood foods, drink beer, and reminisce about the old country.” and,
“German American singing festivals included both highbrow and lowbrow features.”
The Harmonie Ausflug post cards clearly represent the choristers indulging in the “lowbrow features.”
Animal costumes were favored. Dated 1909 on front.
An actual animal.
Not just singers, but a marching band!
“My wife’s husband has gone to the country “but oh you Kid!”
Taking the waters at Boyes.
A zeppelin (invented by Ferdinand von Zeppelin, don’t ya know)? Seems to be hanging from a cable over the pool.
All photos, dated 1909, are by the prolific Charles Weidner.
The JSTOR article https://daily.jstor.org/german-song-in-america/?utm_source=mcae&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=jstordaily-07102025
Further reading about German American singing societies from a University of the Paicific thesis from 1955 https://scholarlycommons.pacific.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2276&context=uop_etds
The Agua Rica Tour!
George Webber writes:
“You may have heard that I am starting a new historic walking tour in your neighborhood. It is called the Agua Rica Tour. I was asked to create such a tour…that will take place solely on the grounds of the Sonoma Mission Inn….by the new general Manager Karim Ikrimah last year.
Since then, CW Bayer and I have delved deeply into the historical record….and am now good friends with Reverend Leavenworth, Capt. Boyes, and Rudy Lichtenberg. Well…except for Thaddeus Minor Leavenworth….no one could be actual friends with him….”
George and CW are well-known actors, historians and radio personalities (yes, we still have radio!) in Sonoma Valley. The tour is an absolute blast! Our history is full of great characters, and these guys really bring them to life.
The tour runs Friday through Monday, starts at 10AM, and adult admission is $25, kids free.
Here is the link to sign up.
M. K. Cady of Agua Caliente Springs
Martin Kellog Cady was born in New London Connecticut in 1847. From the History of New London County, Connecticut (1882), a biographical sketch of the elder Martin K. Cady, who was a prominent businessman in New London in the mid 19th century, listing his children, says “Martin Kellog, eldest son, is assistant coiner at the United States Mint at San Francisco, and has been for some years. He married Jeannie B. daughter of Hon. Charles Gorham, of Marysville, CA.” The book was published in 1882 but must have been written earlier because our M K Cady had left the Mint and settled in Sonoma Valley by 1881.
In that year the Index Tribune tells us, “M.K. Cady, formerly of the San Francisco mint, buys Alexander farm,” and that it is “Located on the Santa Rosa and Sonoma road, about three miles from the pioneer city.(Sonoma)” Also in 1882, Cady established a distillery and wine cellar (see map), built of stone from a “quarry on his own farm in the “Flowery” district.”
An advertisement in the Index Tribune in June of 1885 informs that the Agua Caliente Hotel, under the proprietorship of M. K. Cady will be opening in June of that year, so the resort was founded between 1881 and 1885.
An puff piece in an 1889 issue of the Index Tribune read, in part, “the famous health-giving springs, delightful location and basalt block interests of this progressive little village is destined at no distant day to make it a place of considerable importance. The town was laid out a little over a year ago (incorrect!) by M.K. Cady, one of Sonoma Valley’s most energetic and public-spirited men. The railroad runs through the place which boasts of an express office, post office, schoolhouse, hotel general merchandising store, butcher shop, and a blacksmiths shop. During the spring and summer months the Agua Caliente Springs Hotel is crowded with health and pleasure seekers who come to lave in its health restoring water and bask in never failing sunshine and balmy breezes. An Episcopal Church will be erected a Agua Caliente this summer.”
In 1888 Cady sells to the Verano Land Company: “M.K. Cady of Agua Caliente has sold his hotel property and villa sites in that town to the Verano Land Company. Mr. Cady retains his winery and some forty acres of choice vineyard and will build a residence on the heights overlooking the wine cellar.” (This could be the site that became Keaton’s Shack.) After six months, Cady takes the property back. It seems, it has been closed the entire time “owing to a disagreement among the directors, who have been fighting like cats and dogs…” The Verano Land Company developed the “towns” of Verano and El Verano. Their brochure touting the developments is priceless early 20th century hype.
In 1888 Cady runs for county supervisor and is elected. The Index Triubne says “Mr. Cady is the right man in the right place and the people of Sonoma and Vallejo Townships ought to congratulate themselves on having so able a man to look after their affairs at the county seat”
Also in 1888 “A petition was received from citizens of Sonoma road district praying for a new road from the iron bridge across Sonoma creek at Sonoma to the town of El Verano, and for the abandonment of the old road from the old bridge to where the same connects with Petaluma Avenue. On motion of Mr. Coulter, the same was received and placed on file, the accompanying bond approved and W. K. Nichols, M.K. Cady and G. C. P. Sears were appointed to view and lay out said proposed new road and report at the next meeting.” Please see The Arroyo of Arroyo Road
Interestingly, in 1891 the IT opined “(Cady’s) hotel is located in one of the most picturesque spots in California, and is destined at no distant day to be to this State what Saratoga is to New York.” However, they weren’t reckoning with Calistoga, which was so named because it was deemed the Saratoga of California.
All was not smooth sailing for Mr. Cady. In a September 1893 article in the IT headlined ”Agua Caliente Post Office Squabble. Cady and Morris on Top-Postmaster John Austin Down and in Jail,” we learn that Austin was the owner of a general store in Agua Caliente, which housed the post office. He also ran a bar that competed with Cady’s. Morris was the “mail Messenger” responsible for carrying the mail from the railroad depot to the Post Office. Morris and Austin had bad blood between them stemming from a fist fight the previous July. Morris and Cady wanted to get the Post Office moved to Cady’s’ resort. They accused Austin of opening their mail, and Austin was arrested and taken to jail in San Francisco. Austin claimed he was framed in order get the post office away from him.
That November, Cady was indeed appointed by President Cleveland to be post master of Agua Caliente, “a little old one-horse affair, the salary amounting to from $3 to $5 per month.” In October the story took a strange turn as Austin, having written to his wife in Agua Caliente that he would be home the next day, disappeared. Then, on April 7, 1894: “The Santa Rosa Republican is authority for the statement that John Austin, ex Postmaster of Agua Caliente, near this place, recently fell from a scaffold in a town in South America and sustained injuries that resulted in his death.”
Apparently Cady defaulted on his mortgage in 1895. “A Mr. Dean of San Francisco took possession this week of the Agua Caliente Springs ranch to satisfy a mortgage of $25,000 executed by the former owner, M,K. Cady, who has been in possession of the property for over fifteen years {making Cady’s arrival in the valley no later than 1879}. The Hotel, swimming baths, wine cellar and hotel grounds have been disposed of by Mr. Dean to Dr. Nordin of Alameda, who will improve the hotel and grounds and conduct the same as a first class summer resort and sanitarium. Mr. Cady has leased for the present the handsome cottage which was erected near the wine cellar a few years ago by Mr. McGrew of San Francisco.”
However, Doctor and Mrs. Nordin did not see eye-to-eye. Shortly after he purchased the resort and investing $30,000 of her money in refurbishing it, Mrs. Nordin sued her husband, whom she says took her money under false pretenses and she wanted it back.
The Index Tribune, after saying that Mr. Cady “ran the resort into the ground,” informs us that Cady was appointed receiver of the property during the law suit!
“The bondsmen for M. K. Cady, who was appointed receiver of the Agua Caliente Springs by Judge Crawford, are J. B. Moris and Horace Appleton. Each swears he was worth $3000 over and above his just debts and qualified for $6,000 double the amount of the bond.”
The story continues. September 1895, “The Nordin case, which is the all absorbing topic of conversation in this valley, was resumed in the Superior Court last Monday. It will be recollected that last week Judge Crawford put and injunction on the Agua Caliente springs Resort, appointed M. K. Cady receiver of the property, and accepted as his bondsmen H.B. Morris and Horace Appleton.
Later court action: “The proceedings Monday was devoted to filing a motion to dissolve the injunction….” Nordin alleges that Cady is insolvent, and “that…during the greater portion of the time since his appointment as receiver (has been) under the influence of intoxicants.”
Nordin continues to allege that Cady has fired all the staff and put his wife, daughter, niece on the payroll, and “that the Cady tribe has taken up their abode on the promises.”
Additionally “The affidavit says the order appointing Cady as receiver covers all the personal property on the premised and that some of the guests at the hotel wish to leave, and that Mr. Cady has refused to let them have their trunks and wearing apparel”!
November 9, 1895-The Nordin suit was continued. “The property is still in the hands of Trustee Cady. Dr. Nordin is residing in San Francisco and Mrs. Nordin is the guest of Alameda friends.”
April 11, 1896, the suit is settled with Dr. Nordin getting $1000 and Mrs. Nordin getting the property, but no word of what happened to the “Cady Tribe.” Mrs. Nordin continued running the resort. Details are in short supply. The magnificent hotel burned some time before 1916, when the new, stone building was built.
Martin Kellog Cady died November 18, 1903, in San Francisco.
All quotes are from the Sonoma Index Tribune unless otherwise noted.
Sonoma Index Tribune and many images courtesy of the Sonoma Valley Historical Society
The Agua Caliente Resort, and vicinity, was well documented by photographers. The following is a slide show of some of those photos and post cards.
Cazes Resort
Updated below
Jean Marie Cazes was born in Nestier,France in 1867. He arrived in the US in 1883 (aboard the ship Chateau Lafitte!). After spending a significant amount of time in New York, working in the wine business, he decamped for California and the Valley of the Moon in 1920.
In 1922, Jean and Genevieve Cazes started construction of their new resort on the Sonoma Highway in Fetters Hot Springs. In April of that year, according to the Index Tribune, “The new hotel and café being erected for Mr. and Mrs. Jean Cazes on the highway near Fetters, is nearing completion. The Cazes sold their resort in the hills and are to engage in business in the new quarters. A twenty-five room hotel and grill will provide fine accommodations for guests and a good season is expected.” The name of their “resort in the hills” is unknown as of this writing.
Prohibition being the law of the land, raids of public establishments became common. The Index Tribune (via the S.F. Chronicle) tells us, in September of 1922, under the headline “Prohibition Agents Raid Springs Resorts,” Jean Cazes was arrested along with some other resort proprietors. He eventually received a $250 fine for his transgressions.
By 1924, Jean Cazes had sold his resort to a Domenico Rovigna, who conitunued business under the Cazes name. (However, a 1942 article about a robbery at the resort, calls Mrs. Cazes “the proprietor.” It also erroneously calls her “Mrs. Doree Cazes.” Her name was Genevieve.)
Jean Cazes died in Fetters Springs in 1941. His obit in the IT said he “was among the first café proprietors in Fetters Springs and…had been prominent in California wine circles before that for many years.”
Genevieve Cazes was also born in France, in 1881, and died in 1970 at her home on Mountain Avenue, Fetters Springs. Her obituary states she was the owner of Maison Doree for fifty-five years, which suggests she still owned it when she died.
The Historic Survey, done for the Redevelopment project in 1984 (below), listed the construction date for the Cazes building as approximately 1915. Dan Petersen, the author of the report, noted , “this collection of early commercial buildings should be restored as contributors to the historic character of this community,” If only this suggestion had been acted on! However, the buildings(s) do exist (in 2024), in highly altered states.
A subsequent Historic Survey done in 2004, listed the construction date as 1925 and the building “the Jean M. and Genevieve Cazes residence.” The authors seem to be unaware of the existence of the resort.
In 2008 I created the Valley of the Moon Main Stem Photo Archive in order to preserve for future artists and historians and folk in general, a snapshot of what the two-mile stretch of highway looked like. It contains over 400 photographs. I donated a copy to the Sonoma County Library and the Sonoma Valley Historical Society, in digital form and on paper.
Index Tribune, first photo, and Historic Resource Reports courtesy of the Sonoma Valley Hisotrical Society. Many thanks to Joan Lounibos for research.
For more on French families in the Valley see https://springsmuseum.org/2020/12/13/dutil-french-cottages-verdiers/
UPDATE! Historian and writer Joan Lounbous contributes this essay detailing more about the Cazes and Prohibition in the Valley. Thank you Joan for the wonderful research and writing:
JEAN MARIE CAZES (1867-1941) –Resort Owner and Bootlegger
Jean Marie CAZES was a wine loving Frenchman who wasn’t going to let a few raids get in between he and his wine glass!
In October 1925, Jean Marie Cazes’ Maison Doree resort in Fetters Springs, just north of Boyes Hot Springs and our El Verano, was raided by the Feds—again: “57 Varieties—Not Pickles—Raid’s Loot. ”If you don’t see what you want, ask for it,” was apparently the slogan of Cazes, resort owner of Sonoma Valley, according to County Detective E W Westphall. Cazes’ bar contained the 57 varieties, more of less, according to Westphall—and he didn’t mean pickles, though it might be called a pickling stock. The detective, leading a squad of county officers, gave out the following list of assorted liquors seized in a raid yesterday: 21 gallons of White Wine, 10 quarts of Red Wine, 2 quarts of Port Wine, 1 quart of Sherry Wine, 1 quart of Vermouth, 2 quarts of Berry Cordial, 1 quart of Creme de Menthe, 1 quart of good Scotch, 1.5 quarts of Jackass. The liquor, which was contained in 30 kegs of various sizes, was hidden all over Cazes’ little resort building, opposite the site of the former Fetters clubhouse, according to Westphall. Cazes will be arrested Monday and is to appear before the local justice court. “ [The Press Democrat Sun, Oct 18, 1925 ·Page 4]
Jean Marie CAZES was born on 16 APR 1867 in Nestier, Bordeaux, France and died on 28 Feb 1941 in Fetters Springs, Sonoma, Valley. He and his wife, —Genevieve Batistine BÉGUÉ m CAZES. (1878–1970) who was born on 8 June 1878 in Hèches (Section de Rebouc), Hautes-Pyrénées, France and died in 1 June 1970 in Fetters Hot Springs, Sonoma Valley, California, —had arrived in the Valley about 1915—just as the our Aunt Annie Lounibos Chauvet (1872-1960) and her brother, our grandfather, Jean Baptiste Lounibos (1873-1929) were losing their own vintner family. (Germain Charles (1870-1913), Jean-Pierre (1840-1917) and Paul Emile (1876-192). Tuberculosis took the brothers, while some say their father died from the shock of Prohibition looming over their heritage.). Our Grandfather Jean Baptiste did not test the Feds, especially since he had a large family to support, and by 1919 he had already closed the Pioneer Liquor Store on Main Street in Petaluma, and opened the IXL Hatchery located on Baker Street, behind their 519 Upham Street home. But he did always keep a keg of Brandy in his cellar.
It is difficult to imagine what Prohibition did to a place like our Valley of the Moon, but Jean Marie Cazes’ story gives us a glimpse into how the wretched Volstead Act played out in a region whose heritage and primary industry had always been the cultivation of the vines—all thanks to a hint from historian Mike Acker of the Springs Museum which proved to open that glimpse into The Valley through those long years of Prohibition. Jean Marie and many of his fellow Frenchmen and neighbors in the valley did not let Prohibition stopped them in their lifestyle. And through the 1920s the Federal agents of the county visited them at least annually. By 1922, the Resort owners of The Springs were already labeled as “notorious” in their operations. [The Prohibition era Jan 17, 1920 – Dec 5, 1933 was the period when the United States prohibited the production, importation, transportation, and sale of alcoholic beverages.]
As the Turks were attempting to re-gain their foothold in Europe by pushing into Constantinople, on the World front, the San Francisco Journal and Daily Journal of Commerce announced in adjacent headlines that the “Police Campaign Against Bootleg Liquor Is Begun.” Their aim was to raid and close several well-known spots in the City flagrantly violating the Prohibition laws, but also notorious bootleg resorts in Sonoma Valley: Deputy Director C H Wheeler began the investigation into the case of a blind and partially paralyzed man who was found wandering in the neighborhood of San Francisco Hospital. When discovered, he had on his person twenty-four small bottles of wood alcohol whisky which he is believed to have been drinking. (Wood alcohol whisky will cause blindness.). Twelve others were also arrested on this day. Also ordered was the destruction of 625 quarts of “home brew” seized at the Phoenix Bottling Works in Guerrero Street since the bottles were exploding in the government warehouse. Another fellow was arrested for transporting liquor in his automobile. He was fined $150 and his machine was confiscated. By the time they got to the Valley resorts, George Darling of Darling’s resort in Boyes Springs, E Peters of Cabinot resort in Boyes Springs, our Jean Marie Cazes of Maison Doree in Fetters Springs, and J Moore of Shamrock Sun resort in Fetters Springs—were also arrested. [Sep 16, 1922]
The following year, we see that “a fine of $250 was paid by Jean Cazes of Fetters Springs when he appeared in the justice court at Glen Ellen—charge of violating the county Liquor ordinance. ALSO, B Mori–same. [Santa Rosa Republican Feb 14, 1923]
The following year in February 1924, it appears that Jean Marie Cazes was ready to throw in the towel. He is selling lots in Agua Caliente Park, and The Maison Doree is advertised For Sale as well. “Spend your vacations in Sonoma Valley. Two blocks’ walk to station, baths and all amusements. Meet parties at station by appt. Excellent home cooking. Rates $14 per week. JEAN CAZES Prop. Phone 4-F-3 Fetters Spring, CAL.” [Oakland Tribune Jun 22, 1924] But it was only a lease he obtained: “Mr and Mrs Jean M CAZES proprietors of the French resort near Agua Caliente, have leased the property to Domingo Rovigna of South San Francisco, for two years with an option to buy—for $13,000 during lease.” But again, while the two men were celebrating their new transaction at the resort, “the Feds dropped by to pay their respects.” Domingo Rovigna, who purchased Maison Doree, Fetters, last week from Jean Cazes, was charged $300. [Press Democrat Mar 13, 1924 and Petaluma Argus-Courier Mar 28, 1924]
Remarkably, Jean Marie Cazes is also filing papers for his Naturalization (Citizenship) at the same time. Two days later, he is again raided at his resort: 57 Varieties–Not Pickles–Raid’s Loot. “If you don’t see what you want, ask for it,” was Cazes slogan in the bar. Confiscated from stash holes throughout the resort were: 21 gal White Wine, 10 gal Red Wine, 2 qts Port, 1 qt Sherry, 1 qt Vermouth, 2 qts Berry Cordial. 1 qt Creme de Menthe, 1 qt Good Scotch, 1.5 qts Jackass. [ Press Democrat Oct 18, 1925 ]. His fine, this time, was $250 paid four days later when he appeared before M T Vaughan in Santa Rosa.
In 1928, the “Drys again attempted to clean up the Valley, raiding six resorts: Joe/Rose Udvic-Our Resort-El Verano; Jean Cazes–Maison Doree-Fetters, Matthew Bock-Quick Meal Lunch Counter-Fetters; Roy Burchane-Stone House; Carl Steffan-Caliente Villa-; Mrs E Johnson-Italian American Hotel-all Aqua Caliente [Santa Rosa Republican May 7, 1928]. Three of them (the Sonoma Rum Trio) were hauled off to San Francisco to the US Commissioner, Francis Kroll, for selling illicit liquor. This time the fine was a bit steeper: arrested 5 May: Jean Cazes, Matt Bock, and Eva Johnson–$1000 each. All posted the fine. [The Press Democrat May 10, 1928 ]. And so it continued—Arrested last night was John Cazes, 62; he pleaded guilty to possession of small quantities beer, wine and Jackass Brandy $250–along with three others–including Louis Dueret, 28. [Santa Rosa Republican. Sat, Aug 03, 1929]
Jean Marie Cazes died on 28 February 1941, in Fetters Springs, at the age of 73, the beloved husband of Genevieve Cazes and father of Marguerite Cazes. His daughter Marguerite, by then, was married to Jess Reinking, the manager of Spreckles Golf Course, and they lived next door to her parents in Fetters.
One would like to imagine that Jean Marie Cazes’ wife, Genevieve Batistine BÉGUÉ, was removed from the bootlegging activities pf her husband—but that was not quite the case, it seems. In 1928, when Genevieve attempted to apply for citizenship, it was found that her character witness for citizenship, and their neighbor with the Quick Meals Lunch Counter in Fetters, was in jail —for bootlegging. Matt Bock was a regular associate of her husband Jean Marie, at several of their arrests for bootlegging. —“Witness for Naturalization Hearing in Jail—Matt Bock, witness for Genevieve Baistine Cazes of Fetters Springs, was recently arrested for Liquor Possession and his case is pending in the federal courts; her application was continued pending the outcome of Bock’s case.” [Santa Rosa Republican. May 24, 1928]. Due to Bock, May Have to File Anew. If Bock is convicted–Genevieve would have to file a new naturalization application (after maybe a five year wait.). On 24 Jan 1929. She again “Loses Citizenship Application—Bootlegger Bock as Witness. Her application was dismissed without prejudice. She must now wait five years to begin application process again–due to character witness Matt Bock who was found guilty of liquor possession.” [Santa Rosa Republican. Thu, Jan 24, 1929 ·Page 8]
Even after the repeal of Prohibition, Genevieve was getting herself into trouble. “Complaint charging Genevieve B Cazes, who operates a beer parlor at Fetters Springs, had distilled spirits “with intent to sell.” Only has a beer license. ALSO–Four more stills seized in Valley. [Santa Rosa Republican. Tue, Feb 18, 1936 ·Page 5]
Three years later, when she again tried to apply for citizenship (Naturalization) she drew the ire of Judge Comstock: “Widely known Sonoma Valley woman, Genevieve Cazes of Fetters Springs, wife of a resort owner—was insistent she had never run afoul of the law. Her false statements were confronted by Judge Comstock with evidence—of two arrests. Application was continued. [Petaluma Argus-Courier Jan 19, 1939]. Eighteen months later she applied again and was confronted, again,—this time by Judge Geary: “Judge Geary denied application for citizenship by Genevieve Cazes due to false information on her application that she had never been arrested. She was warned to tell the truth when she fills out new application next year. Geary warned her that “the truth is one of the first requisites of citizenship.” She may file again next year. [Santa Rosa Republican. May 11-12, 1939]. Genevieve was finally admitted to citizenship in Nov 1942 by Judge Geary.
Four years later, Genevieve re-married, on 7 May 1946. “Justin Coulier, 59, of Sonoma, and Genevieve Bastistine Cazes, 63, of Fetters Springs.” “Widely known residents of Sonoma Valley are Mrs Genevieve B Cazes, Fetters Springs, and Justin Coulier, Sonoma, who has operated a resort near Sonoma. The bride, a widow, is conducting a cafe and resort once conducted by her former husband. [Press Democrat May 8, 1946]
Justin Coulier had been a Hotel Keeper (Hotel Arno and Hotel Idora) in San Francisco prior to his move to Sonoma in about 1923 with his first wife Marie Delbruc (1886-1942) They had purchased the old Maurel Villa (formerly owned by the late John Maurel.) In 1933, we see them developing an artesian well on the property which was located on a lane opposite Sonoma Valley High School. The well was said “to have sulphur qualities.“ The new proprietor, Justin Coulier, says the artesian well has wonderful flow—like the waters of The Springs section of Sonoma Valley. Fountains, pools, and bathing are contemplated. [Petaluma Argus-Courier Feb 09, 1933 from Index-Tribune]
Justin lists his profession as Farmer in the June 1940 Census, but in August 1940, we read: “Brandy Still Seized at Sonoma, when the Feds raided the ranch of Justin Coulier on a lane opposite Sonoma Valley High School, south of Sonoma. They discovered there a 5 gal still and untaxed brandy. Pleaded guilty-$100 fine or 50 days jail. [Petaluma Argus-Courier Thu, Aug 15, 1940]
So—when Genevieve Batistine BÉGUÉ w’d CAZES married Justin COULIER in 1946, we see that she was continuing on with her numerous bootlegging associations. Justin did not last long though, dying in Sonoma on 10 Jan 1950 at the age of 62. Genevieve lived on for another twenty years, still working at her Cazes’ Maison Doree Restaurant (French and Italian Dinners) in Fetters Springs. She died at her home at 95 Mountain Avenue on 1 June 1970, at the age of 89 years. She had lived in The Valley for 58 years and had been owner of Cazes Maison Doree restaurant for 55 years. (Curiously, also listed near her obituary is one for Rosa Kruschwitz, 86, also of 95 Mountain Avenue in Fetters Springs. A native of Germany, with one daughter Freida Hagan. Rosa had lived in Sonoma Valley for 49 years. Living at the same address with Genevieve, Rosa had died the day before Genevieve.) [JAL Sept 2024—with special thanks to Michael Acker, Artist and Director of the Springs Museum in Sonoma Valley. Mike has written further information of Jean Marie Cazes, especially regarding his earlier life, in a biography posted in August 2024 on The Springs website]
Joan Lounibos 2024-
The Sonoma Valley Grange
2024 is the Centennial Year of Sonoma Valley Grange #407
The Grange was founded in Washington D.C. in 1867 to advocate for farmers. America became less rural, and the Grange evolved into a general community service organization.
On May 6, 1924, some residents of Sonoma Valley met with the Master of the Sebastopol Grange in the Sonoma High School auditorium to organize a Grange for the Valley. The event was important enough to be reported on the front page of the Index Tribune. The IT devoted several paragraphs to the historic accomplishments of the Grange nation-wide, ending by pointing out “one of its grandest achievements is the establishment of rural mail delivery and parcel post in all sections of the country…to publicly proclaim that if it was right for the government to carry mail to the homes of people in the cities, it would be right for it to carry mail the homes of people in the country…” It’s important to notice that things we take for granted had to be advocated for in the past. This kind of advocacy is at the heart of the purpose of the Grange.
One of the main functions of the Grange is to lobby elected representatives on issues relevant to farmers (and community wellbeing in general.) This is done by issuing resolutions. In 1926, Grange #407 resolved, “Whereas: Country banks, through mergers with city banks chains have largely degenerated into agencies for the collecting country deposits to be loaned to city people for riotous living(!) Resolved: ” that “ the California State Grange urge its delegates to consider with an open mind any plan…” to create, “a chain of purely rural banks controlled by farmers.” This shows how radical the Grange was in those days.
By 1928 the membership put forth a “Proposal for a new Grange Hall,” stating, in part, “Whereas, the Sonoma Valley Grange, Number 407, has prospects of increasing their membership, and, Whereas, the Sonoma Valley Grange is paying quite a sum of rent, Be it Resolved, that we the Sonoma Valley Grange, begin laying plans for creating a fund whereby in the near future we may own our own building….”
It took a while. It wasn’t until 1934 that the Grange was able to buy the building on Sonoma Highway from Selig Rosenthal. The IT reported on the front page, on April 6, 1934, that Grange #407 had “purchased the social hall on the highway near Verano from S. Rosenthal…The hall, built originally in connection with the resort (Rosenthal’s), is to be the new home of the Grangers, and they plan to add a dining room and in time make other nice improvements” which they proceeded to do during the next few years.
1934 was the middle of the Great Depression. In that year Grange #407 wrote a letter to the Secretary of the Interior, Harold Ickes, protesting a National Recovery Administration regulation requiring farmers to buy a minimum of one hundred gallons of gasoline to receive a lower price. “The financial statements of the oil companies show large earnings,” they stated, and they resolved that they “they protest(ed) vehemently” against the regulations.
Beginning with its founding in 1867, women were prominent in Grange leadership, serving as presidents (masters), secretaries, and treasurers. Eunice Peterson , a charter member and past master (president) of the Sonoma Valley Grange, was the first woman to serve on the Sonoma-Marin Fair board in 1940 and 1941 and ran for state assembly in 1938.
During the 1940s Grange 407 remained active, and progressive, in political matters. In that year, at a Six County conference held at the Rutherford Grange Hall, the members resolved,
“Whereas: the present war hysteria has encouraged reactionary groups to violate the civil rights of religious and political minorities. And Whereas: unlawful action of this sort was the first step toward the complete loss of freedom in the countries now ruled by dictators. Therefore, Be It Resolved: that the Grange members here assembled, go on record as strongly opposed to these extra-legal practices, and we demand that our law enforcement officers give to theses minorities the full protection guaranteed to them under the Bill of Rights in Constitution of the United State of America.”
This sounds eerily relevant today.
Appropriate to the Grange radical tradition, in 1952 the California State Employees Union Local 14 met at the Hall. Executive Secretary Richard L. Rumage “lashed out at the use of what he termed “labor spies” in state hospitals…” but the Grange was always also about family and tradition. In May of 1950 the Home Economics Club of the Grange held, at its monthly luncheon, a special Mother’s Day program honoring the oldest mothers present, Mrs. Susy Musanti, 84, and Mrs. Aline Lourdeaux, 85.
In 1948 Grange #407 incorporated as a “general nonprofit corporation.”
In 1975 Grange #407 celebrated its 50th anniversary at the hall. “Arnold Griewe was master of ceremonies for the evening. Singing and gymnastics (!) by Lisa Lanning and Julie Griewe were performed for the 120 in attendance,” the Index Tribune tells us. Past masters Florence Sullivan, Ernie Semino, John Spraks Myrtle Bowie and Clarence Jenkins were honored.
The organization prospered into the 1980s, putting on pancake breakfasts, flea markets, and serving as a polling place, among many other events and functions. However, like Granges all over the country, the membership began to dwindle and age. In 2005 the Index Tribune published an article under the headline, “The Graying of the Grange,” interviewing older members Edith Lanning, Arvilla MacAllister, and Marianne Erickson. Just a few years later,some younger folks, with interests in wine and food and community building, joined and revitalized the organization, much to the delight of the old timers.
A major building project, partially funded by generous donors and the local Rotary Club, produced new ADA compliant restrooms, and a new commercial kitchen, vastly improving the usefulness of the Hall. The hall continued to be a popular rental venue, especially for the Hispanic community, as it hosted many a quinceañera and baby shower.
Fun at the Grange!
Your humble correspondent has been a member since 2008, and served a president for a number of years. He also designed the mural (seen in the very first photo), which was painted in 2010 by Randy Sue Johnson, with funds provided by a County Redevelopment Façade Improvement grant.
Some other things needed updating:
Index Tribune, documents and photos courtesy of the Sonoma Valley Historical Society. Other photos by author.
Christmas 1923
A sampler of Christmas from the Index Tribune, one hundred years ago.
Sonoma was in the grip of movie fever. Actor/producer/director/swindler Harold Binney had arrived to set up his studio. Local were recruited to be extras in the “Account of the No Account Count.” Alas, Binney absconded having written bad checks, and Sonoma as Hollywood North never materialized.
See you at the Union Hotel for Christmas dinner? Oh, that’s right. They tore it down and built an unlovely Bank of America! However, they were considerate enough to erect a bronze plaque commemorating what they had destroyed.
Directors included Sam Sebastiani, and Frank Wedekind.
Sweet!
I wonder how Mr. Abbott came by the molds. Spoils of war?
In 1923 it did not take much to produce contentment, apparently!
“Bring along your rifle!”
By 1923 the railroads had significant competition from bus lines. The egg laying contest had thirty six entries, eleven of them from outside California! The IOOF building is still there and in great shape.
Sonoma Index Tribune courtesy of the Sonoma Valley Historical Society
Pine Wagner, Pharmacist
Along with Marion Greene, Emma Fetters, and Mary Fazio, Pine Wagner was one of the important 20th century entrepreneurs in The Springs who happened to be women. Although the California Board of Pharmacy does not keep old records (shamefully!) Pine Wagner must have been one of the first women to be licensed as a pharmacist in the state.
She graduated from the University of Creighton school of pharmacy, in Omaha, Nebraska in 1917, eventually making her way to Bakersfield, then Sonoma Valley around 1944.
She established Valley Drug in 1946, originally in a building on the highway owned by L.E. “Bud” Castner. Castner, once a chicken farmer, had opted to join the less fragrant and more profitable insurance business of a Mr. Mouyer, in the 1940s. After acquiring the building from Mouyer, according to an article in the Index Tribune in 1977, “Some of the space in the building Castner leased out. In this way he brought the first doctor, the first dentist and the first drugstore to Boyes Springs. They were Dr. Michael Mikita, the medico, Dr. Holly Christensen and Miss Pine Wagner.” Judge William Downey also held court in the building.
In 1951, Wagner moved her pharmacy to the new Plaza Center building, which had just been enlarged. It was built on the site of the old Boyes Springs Plaza and railroad depot. It now houses the Boyes Hot Springs post office. (Below)
Wagner owned a duplex on 4th Avenue in Boyes Springs. We know this because the Index Tribune published notices of building permits and noted hers, for $1200 worth of termite repairs, in 1966.
She sold the business in 1962. Valley Drug stayed in business into the 1980s.
She died in 1975 at the age of 80. She had been a pharmacist for 58 years.
Index Tribune and photographs courtesy of the Sonoma Valley Historical Society.
Thanks also to the Sonoma County Library and to the California Board of Pharmacy (not)
Murals in the Springs
Public art grows in fits and starts hereabouts but we are starting to build up a nice stock of murals. Here we look at four of them.
The mural on the front of the Sonoma Valley Grange building, located at 18627 Sonoma Highway. The Grange has owned the building, which was probably originally a dance hall, since 1934. See (https://springsmuseum.org/2022/06/28/the-sonoma-valley-grange-traditionchange-and-renewal/) for more about the Grange. Through the Redevelopment Façade Improvement project, the Grange got funding for the mural in 2010. It was designed by Michael Acker and painted in collaboration with Randy Sue Collins. It depicts a bit of Boyes Hot Springs and Grange history. It being on the west facing wall, it takes a terrific beating from the sun, and has been restored twice.
The Republic of Thrift building at 17496 Sonoma Highway has two murals sponsored by the Monarch Project (https://www.socoimm.org/) along with others. On the west facing wall is the giant Monarch butterfly, completed in June 2020. According to the Index Tribune, “Artist Rima Makaryan, just 17 years old, painted a Monarch butterfly as part of “The Monarch Project,” a Sonoma County nonprofit organization working to tell the stories of immigrants and empower the community.” “We are working to have a conversation about immigration through art,” said Makaryan. “Oftentimes immigrants are labeled aliens or talked about negatively. The goal of the Monarch Project is to find beauty in the subject.” The mural, painted on the west-facing wall of the thrift store, features a Monarch butterfly filled with words describing the immigrant experience, such as resilience, hope, amor, sacrifice and fear. Makaryan noted, “The words are meant to embody the journey and diversity of all migrants. It’s all about the beauty of the topic, good and bad.”
On the east wall a fantastical spray-paint mural by the artist Chor Boogie (https://chorboogie.com/), along with a crew of high school students was painted in 2018. the Led by Sonoma Valley Museum of Art, community partners were Artescape and La luz Center. Co-sponsors were the California Arts Council, the NEA, and the Bank of Marin.
The building at 17400 Sonoma Highway displays yet another Monarch Project mural. Completed in June 2021, it features an image of Dmitra Smith, “…a powerful force fighting against racism in Sonoma County,” according to their website. “Ms. Smith is the former Chair of the Sonoma County Commission on Human Rights, and was the program manager for the Junior Commission, having mentored over 100 Sonoma County students between 2013- 2020. Smith is a co-founder of the essential workers’ mutual aid collective Food for All – Comida para Todos.”
At the time the mural was painted, the building was the home of Sonoma Originals skate shop. Sadly, it is now empty.
We actually have a lot of art in the Springs, some of it “official,” as the above are, some harder to find, personal expressions, often ephemeral, but worth noting, as we will do in future posts
Index Tribune courtesy of the Sonoma Valley Historical Society
springs museum 